1946 King David Hotel BOMBING - Forgotten History

Summary

In a riveting dive into the past, this episode of Forgotten History explores the 1946 bombing of the King David Hotel, an act by Jewish militants against British rule in Palestine. The narration, led by former history professor and veteran Colin Heaton, elucidates the historical tensions between the British authorities and Jewish communities. The bombing, a response to decades of restrictive policies against Jewish immigration, culminated in a tragic explosion that killed 91 people. Despite warning calls prior to the incident, the British failed to evacuate, escalating animosity and leading to increased Jewish resistance against colonial rule. The event highlighted the complex dynamics of post-WWII geopolitics and foreshadowed the eventual establishment of Israel in 1948.

Highlights

• Jewish fighters, frustrated by unfulfilled promises, plotted the King David Hotel bombing against the British authorities. 🤯
• The bombing was a direct response to British restrictions on Jewish immigration despite the ongoing Holocaust. 🚪
• Warnings were ignored by British officials leading to a devastating explosion that underscored their oversight. 🏨
• The incident accelerated the British withdrawal and the UN's eventual establishment of Israel. 🏃‍♂️
• Tensions from the hotel bombing highlighted the larger conflict that would lead to Israel's creation two years later. 🔥

Key Takeaways

• The British agreed to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine after WWI with the Balfour Declaration, but this promise was complicated by other secret agreements like the Sykes-Picot Agreement. 🗺️
• Tensions rose between Jewish communities and the British due to restrictive immigration policies, leading to acts of defiance such as the bombing of the King David Hotel. 💥
• Despite warnings, the British underestimated the threat, resulting in a tragic explosion with 91 fatalities. 🚨
• The bombing forced a reevaluation of British policies but led to harsher measures rather than cooperation with Jewish communities. 📜
• Post-war geopolitics and these events eventually led to the establishment of Israel in 1948. 🌍

Overview

This gripping episode delves into the murky historic waters around the bombing of the King David Hotel—a seminal moment in the Jewish fight for a homeland. With a historical nod to the Balfour Declaration post-WWI and the conflicting Sykes-Picot Agreement, tensions were rife. The British promised a Jewish national home in Palestine, yet their restrictive policies caused frustration, boiling over into revolutionary actions by Jewish groups.

In an act of defiance and desperation, Jewish militants orchestrated a bombing at the hotel, targeting British military and investigation headquarters. Despite warnings, British authorities ignored the threats, resulting in a deadly explosion. This tragic event, claiming 91 lives, illustrated not only the dire circumstances faced by Jews but also the British administration's failure to address mounting pressures.

The aftermath was tense; rather than loosening their grip, the British became more oppressive, further alienating Jewish communities. This worsening situation became a catalyst for Israel's eventual founding in 1948, as international perspectives shifted, recognizing the legitimacy of the Jewish quest for a homeland amidst post-war global realignments.

Chapters

• 00:00 - 02:00: Introduction to British Promises During WWI The introduction discusses the British and French promises made during World War I, specifically the commitment to grant Jewish people their ancestral homeland, Palestine, which was part of the Ottoman Empire. This promise was articulated through the Balfour Declaration on November 2, 1917.
• 02:00 - 04:00: Contradictory Agreements and Tensions in the Middle East The chapter titled 'Contradictory Agreements and Tensions in the Middle East' discusses the British government's support for establishing a national home for the Jewish people in Palestine during World War I. The British aimed to secure Jewish support, particularly in the United States, for the Allied Powers against the Central Powers. Additionally, they hoped a pro-British Jewish settlement in Palestine would help secure the Suez Canal and Egypt, ensuring a vital communication route to British territories.
• 04:00 - 06:00: Jewish Immigration and British Restrictive Policies This chapter delves into the complexities of Jewish immigration to Palestine during the British Mandate period. It discusses the promises made in the Balfour Declaration to the Jewish people and the subsequent confirmation of these promises in a letter from the British Foreign Secretary Arthur Balfour to Baron Lionel Walter Rothschild. Despite these promises, local Muslim communities expressed discontent, leading to tensions in the region. The British defense against honoring these promises involved referencing the Sykes-Picot Agreement, a secret agreement that played a crucial role in altering territorial distributions after World War I.
• 06:00 - 08:00: King David Hotel Bombing: Prelude and Motivation The chapter discusses the historical context and motivations leading up to the King David Hotel bombing. It begins by highlighting the political landscape shaped by secret agreements like the Sykes-Picot Agreement of 1916, which aimed to divide the Middle East between Britain and France, conflicting with promises made in the Balfour Declaration which supported the establishment of a Jewish state. The narrative underscores the longstanding Jewish presence in the region and their growing arrival since the early 19th century, setting the stage for the ensuing tensions and conflicts.
• 08:00 - 10:00: Execution of the Bombing Plan and Aftermath The chapter discusses the tensions and conflicts arising from Jewish immigration to Arab territories, specifically highlighting the persecution of Arabs. It references a video on Israel versus Palestine, indicating the broader historical context. After World War I, agreements supporting Jewish immigration were dismissed due to rising concerns of Muslim uprisings against British occupation in territories including Trans-Jordan and Palestine. This unrest and tension continued to grow after World War II. On July 22nd, 1946, Jewish Freedom Fighters, or terrorists depending on perspective, executed a significant bombing plan, further intensifying the conflict.
• 10:00 - 12:00: Historical Denial and Revelation of Warnings This chapter delves into the events surrounding the bombing of the King David Hotel, an act of militant defiance against British rule, carried out as a result of longstanding frustrations among Jewish communities over the unfulfilled promise of their own state. It explores the background leading up to this act and the subsequent conflict, raising questions about the hotel's significance, its occupants, and the motivations behind its bombing.
• 12:00 - 14:00: British Response and Further Repression Introduction to the chapter with questions about the presence and results of certain actions.
• 14:00 - 16:00: Impact of the King David Hotel Bombing This chapter examines the King David Hotel bombing, which targeted the site housing both the British Military Command and the British Criminal Investigation Division. The text delves into the impending challenges imposed by the British, particularly focusing on the rigid immigration and taxation laws that adversely impacted the Jewish population's rescue efforts during the war.

1946 King David Hotel BOMBING - Forgotten History Transcription

• 00:00 - 00:30 [Music] During World War One the British and French agreed  that as a reward for the Jews who fought with the   Allies in the Middle East and Mesopotamia Theater  of Operations they would be given their ancestral   homeland a place called Palestine carved out  from the old Ottoman Empire. This agreement   was concluded with the Balfour Declaration made  on November 2nd 1917 stating "British support
• 00:30 - 01:00 for the establishment in Palestine of a national  home for Jewish people." The British government   hoped that the Declaration would rally Jewish  opinion especially in the United States to join   the Allied Powers against the Central Powers  during World War I. They hoped also that the   settlement in Palestine of a pro British Jewish  population might help protect the approaches to   the Suez Canal and neighboring Egypt and thus  ensure a vital communication route to British
• 01:00 - 01:30 colonial possessions in India and Southeast Asia.  The promises in the Balfour Declaration were   confirmed in a letter from the British Foreign  Secretary Arthur John Balfour to Baron Lionel   Walter Rothschild leader of the Anglo-Jewish  community who was later included in the British   Mandate over Palestine. But local Muslims were  a little upset about this. The British in their   defense to not honor the Declaration cited  the Sykes-Picot Agreement the secret agreement
• 01:30 - 02:00 between Britain and France concluded the year  before in 1916 by Sir Mark Sykes and Francois   George Picot which essentially divided up the  Middle East under their respective empires.   The secret Sykes-Picot Agreement contradicted  the terms of the Balfour Declaration. The Jews   in fact the world's governments supported the  efforts of a Jewish state as Jews had been living   there for 5,000 years and more had been arriving  in the early 19th century. The Ottomans in fact
• 02:00 - 02:30 allowed this immigration of Jews much to the  detriment of the Arabs whom they persecuted.   See our video on Israel versus Palestine.  After the war the agreement was dismissed due   to the concerns of Muslims rising up against  the British occupation forces in their new   mandates of Trans-Jordan to include Palestine.  Then after World War II those concerns grew in scope. Therefore on July 22nd 1946 Jewish Freedom  Fighters or terrorists depending upon one's
• 02:30 - 03:00 position blew up the King David Hotel in an act of  militant defiance of British rule. This event was   the result of decades of frustration at not having  their own Jewish state as promised. The background   leading up to this event and the broader conflict  that followed is critical to understanding how   and why it occurred. What was the King David  Hotel? Why was it bombed? Who occupied it? Why
• 03:00 - 03:30 were they there? What was the result of the  action? Hello I'm Colin Heaton former history   Professor Army and Marine Corps veteran and  welcome to this episode of Forgotten History.
• 03:30 - 04:00 The King David Hotel was the location of both the  British Military Command and the British Criminal   Investigation Division. The enforcement  of the strict immigration and taxation   laws targeting Jews had hindered saving many  Jews from death during the war and even saving
• 04:00 - 04:30 thousands from starvation and persecution after  the war was halted when they were strapped and   trapped in Soviet held Eastern Europe. The world  was appalled after the Holocaust was exposed which   was the primary reason for the Nuremberg and  subsequent war crimes trials. Ever since the   end of World War I the British policy was to  restrict the Jewish immigration to only 2,500   people per year most coming from Europe and  this had been the law for decades. Jews who   entered illegally were arrested imprisoned  and most were deported even during World War
• 04:30 - 05:00 II. Ships had been refused the right to dock  with Jews fleeing the Holocaust and turned   back forcing them to return to German occupied  Europe condemning their human cargo to certain   death. This happened continuously even after the  Holocaust became known to the world after 1943.   Underground Jewish groups did manage to smuggle  Jews into Palestine via Syria and Persia most of
• 05:00 - 05:30 those escaping from the Soviet Union. The British  afraid of upsetting the Arab Muslim majority and   causing an uprising were ruthless in their  application of the law at the expense of the   Jews. The Jewish Council which operated under  the mandate also denounced the longstanding and   increasing tax laws that targeted Jews more than  anyone else mainly because Jews started businesses   and were successful at agriculture. Increasing  the tension was the knowledge that when the war
• 05:30 - 06:00 in Europe was nearly over the existence of  the death camps which had been liberated was   well known. The Jewish Agency for Immigration  used this information to petition the British   as early as 1942 to allow Jews especially  those Polish Jews released from Siberia under   the agreement that Winston Churchill made with  Joseph Stalin to assist the Allied war effort.
• 06:00 - 06:30 Many of the poles who were released from  the gulags formed the Free Polish Army often   called the "Anders Army" and were Jewish  and Catholic. They volunteered to fight   with the British but their relatives  wanted to go to Palestine. many were   kept in Persia later named Iran and their  ancestors remain there today. The Jewish   Agency had been collecting information on  surviving Jews liberated from the camps   and connecting them with relatives living in  Palestine. The Agency petitioned to reunite family
• 06:30 - 07:00 members and those requests were consistently  denied. Knowing that the Jewish Agency and Council   had a legitimate concern in their petitions with  regard to reuniting families especially with the   creation of the United Nations and with what  had transpired during the Yalta Conference the   British wanted to confiscate these records  and they raided the Jewish Agency on June 2   9th 1946 and confiscated large quantities  of documents and files and placed over 2,500
• 07:00 - 07:30 Jews from all over Palestine accused of illegal  entry under arrest. By this time the "Irgun" or   General Command Authority had seen enough. The  information the British had confiscated about   Jewish Agency operations lists of names of known  survivors including Jewish intelligence activities   in Arab countries was taken to the King David  Hotel and the Jewish agency wanted it all back.
• 07:30 - 08:00 A week later it was learned that 40 Jews who  had been denied immigration some being Poles   who returned home after fighting in the Free  Polish Army were murdered by the communists   in Kielce Poland. Britain's highly restrictive  immigration policy to appease the Muslim majority   in violation of the Balfur Declaration  of 1917 had condemned thousands to death. Many of the dead had relatives in Palestine and  those names were in the Agency's documents which
• 08:00 - 08:30 would have been very bad public relations back  home in Britain for the British occupation forces   and also a violation of the postwar agreements  on the Jewish diaspora. The outrage was felt   throughout the Jewish community and they demanded  that some action be taken and they wanted revenge.   The Igun then decided to take direct covert  military action against the hotel get the
• 08:30 - 09:00 stolen records and make a statement by bombing  the building. They expected military casualties   and that was the plan and the new Irgun leader  the future Prime Minister of Israel Menachem   Begin wanted to avoid civilian casualties in  any operation even among Muslims. The Jewish   fighters managed to enter the hotel many disguised  as British soldiers some as Arabs some as workers   placing explosives. Once all was in place three  telephone calls were placed to the hotel another
• 09:00 - 09:30 call made to the French Consulate and a third call  to the Palestine Post all warning that explosives   in the King David Hotel would soon be detonated.  One operative named Adina Hai- Nisan said that   she called the hotel switchboard 30 minutes  prior to the explosion which was answered but   then ignored. The Irgun carried out a diversionary  first bombing after the bombs were planted in the
• 09:30 - 10:00 King David Hotel. This first diversionary bomb  was placed in a wagon outside shops next to the   Hotel. This first bomb was detonated which broke  several windows but caused no injuries and may   have been intended to cause panic and encourage  evacuation of the building. Whether through hubris   or believing the calls were pranks the hotel was  not evacuated. Begin himself quotes one British   official who supposedly refused to evacuate the  building by saying "We don't take orders from the
• 10:00 - 10:30 Jews" that was a mistake because at 12:30 p.m. the  massive explosion blew through much of the hotel's   south side killing 91 people and injuring 45 more.  In the aftermath six survivors were discovered   buried alive over the next several days under the  rubble in the part that collapsed by soldiers of   the 9th Airborne Squadron Royal Engineers. Among  those casualties were 15 Jews. For a many years
• 10:30 - 11:00 afterward the British denied that they had been  warned in advance but in 1979 a member of the   British Parliament Lord Greville Janner produced  direct evidence that the Irgun had indeed issued   the warning supporting Begin's statement. He  offered the "testimony of a British officer who   heard other officers in the King David Hotel bar  joking about a Zionist threat to the headquarters.   The officer who overheard the conversation  immediately left the hotel and survived."
• 11:00 - 11:30 Also according to Lord Greville Janner Brigadier  General Dudley Sheridan Skelton was head of a   hospital near Jerusalem and a frequent visitor to  the King David Hotel. He was there on the day of   the explosion and wrote a letter to a colleague  in which he said a warning was passed on to the   officers in the bar in rather jocular terms  implying it was a 'Jewish terrorist bluff'.
• 11:30 - 12:00 But despite advice to ignore the bluff' he  decided to leave and thus was out of the   hotel when the explosion took place." Citing  Eldad Harouvi's book "Palestine Investigated:   The Criminal Investigation Department of the  Palestine Police Force 1920 to 1948" the Israel   State Archives noted the British had intelligence  showing the hotel as a possible target for attack   by the Irgun in December December 1945 6  months prior to the attack. The CID asked
• 12:00 - 12:30 to raise security in the hotel including putting  armed soldiers at the Regent's restaurant at the   entrance of the hotel. The Chief Secretary Sir  John Shaw refused to consider these suggestions   with the justification being that there "were not  many places for recreation and fun in Palestine"   and he did not want to foreclose another location.  He continued to refuse to act or even to pass
• 12:30 - 13:00 on the information to the High Commissioner of  Palestine when the CID approached him again with   newer information on the attack plan as the CID  had the plan of attack but did not know exactly   when it would be carried out or what the exact  targets were. Shaw was blamed by one former CID   officer interviewed by Harouvi for the failure  to evacuate the building. Reportedly after the   Irgun called in their warning Shaw said "I'm  not here to take orders from the Jews! I'm here
• 13:00 - 13:30 to give them." This was who Bean cited in his  book "The Revolt" and therefore justifies his writings. The King David Hotel bombing forced  the British to re-evaluate their policies but   rather than work with the Jews in the region  and relax the strict immigration policies they   became even more heavy-handed only increasing  the animosity among the people they controlled.   After the bombing the British police and military  began a roundup of all suspected terrorists. They
• 13:30 - 14:00 also maintained the decades long ban on the  Jewish religious practices on their holiest   of days such as Yom Kippur and Rosh Hoshana and  worshiping at the Western Wall because it offended Muslims. These events would explode again in  a new wave of attacks as the Jews increased   the momentum of their resistance but nothing was  as spectacular as the David Hotel bombing which
• 14:00 - 14:30 we will cover in another video soon. The public  outrage expected against the Jews who were using   gurerilla warfare against the British did not  really materialize. In fact Britain was blamed   for not honoring their previous agreements. Once  the United Nations established the state of Israel   in 1948 Britain no longer had the authority  to impose their laws and restrict Jewish freedoms. Thank you for watching this episode  of Forgotten History. If you liked what you
• 14:30 - 15:00 saw please click like share and subscribe  and if you would like to assist with the   ever increasing cost of production please consider  becoming a channel member and joining our Patreon page. Please check out our merchandise  store and thanks for watching [Music]