Breaking the Boundaries with AI
François Chollet Launches Ndea: A New Wave in AI with AGI Ambitions!
Last updated:
Edited By
Mackenzie Ferguson
AI Tools Researcher & Implementation Consultant
In a groundbreaking move, AI pioneer François Chollet, known for creating Keras, has founded Ndea, a cutting-edge startup focusing on Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). Co-founded with Mike Knoop of Zapier, Ndea promises to revolutionize AGI development through a unique integration of program synthesis and deep learning. This venture marks a significant shift in AI research, aiming to achieve AGI without conventional bottlenecks. Ndea is also introducing a non-profit focused on establishing benchmarks for AGI progress.
Introduction to Ndea and AGI Focus
Advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) have paved the way for the exploration of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) – a level of machine intelligence similar to human cognitive abilities. Among the notable endeavors in this sphere is Ndea, a new AI lab co-founded by François Chollet, creator of Keras, and Zapier's Mike Knoop. This innovative startup aims to bridge the gap between AI and AGI through cutting-edge techniques such as program synthesis married with deep learning approaches.
François Chollet, previously with Google, brings his celebrated experience in AI frameworks like Keras to Ndea, while Mike Knoop contributes insights from his leadership at Zapier. Together, they aspire to transform Ndea into a hub of rapid scientific advancement, tackling both existing and unexplored challenges in AGI development. By focusing on program synthesis, Ndea attempts to enable AI systems capable of adapting and generalizing from limited information, contrasting significantly from existing models deployed by industry giants like OpenAI.
AI is evolving every day. Don't fall behind.
Join 50,000+ readers learning how to use AI in just 5 minutes daily.
Completely free, unsubscribe at any time.
Ndea's AGI-focused approach holds a competitive edge in its distinct methodology. By integrating program synthesis, the company hopes to overcome challenges faced by conventional deep learning systems which often demand vast amounts of data to perform tasks. Program synthesis equips machines with the ability to generate new programs from limited examples, facilitating a more adaptable and robust form of AI that can tackle unexpected problems effectively.
Integral to Ndea's vision is their non-profit initiative, which aims to establish standardized benchmarks for AGI development. Such benchmarks could potentially set new industry standards for evaluating AGI capabilities while fostering an ecosystem of transparent and measurable AI advancements.
Despite the enthusiasm surrounding Ndea's inception, public discourse has raised both excitement and caution. On social media platforms like X and LinkedIn, commentators applaud Ndea's innovative approach, yet cautionary notes about computational challenges and potential societal impacts persist. Concerns about how AGI might redefine human creativity and social content remain central to the dialogue, reflecting broader societal implications associated with advanced AI breakthroughs.
Founders' Backgrounds and Contributions
The founders of Ndea, François Chollet and Mike Knoop, bring a wealth of experience and expertise to the table, making their joint venture a promising endeavor in the pursuit of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). François Chollet is celebrated in the AI community as the creator of Keras, a highly influential open-source software library that has democratized deep learning research. His recent departure from Google to focus on Ndea highlights his commitment to this ambitious project. Chollet is known for his critical perspective on current deep learning systems, which he believes are limited by their dependency on vast datasets and struggle to adapt to new tasks. Instead, he is pioneering program synthesis, a technique aimed at allowing AI to generalize from limited examples, much like human learning processes.
Mike Knoop co-founded Zapier, a company well-regarded for its role in simplifying workflow automation through innovative AI applications. At Ndea, Knoop steps back from daily operations at Zapier but retains a strategic role on its board, reinforcing his dedication to steering innovative paths in AI. His experience at Zapier, particularly in leading AI initiatives, brings a practical edge to Ndea's theoretical ambitions. Knoop envisions Ndea as a hub for rapid scientific advancement, tackling both known and unexplored issues within AGI development. Together with Chollet, he aims to merge intuitive pattern recognition with formal reasoning to create advanced AGI systems.
Under their leadership, Ndea is exploring a unique approach to AGI by integrating program synthesis with deep learning. This hybrid methodology stands out from the strategies of other major players like OpenAI, which largely focus on scaling existing deep learning frameworks. The duo's vision encompasses not just technological development but also ethical and standardized evaluation processes, evidenced by their establishment of a non-profit dedicated to AGI benchmarking. This initiative aims to create industry standards for measuring AGI capabilities, which is vital for the responsible development and deployment of these powerful technologies.
The potential implications of Ndea's work extend far beyond the confines of technological advances. Economically, the program synthesis-based AGI could revolutionize software development by automating coding processes, potentially disrupting current job markets while creating new opportunities in AI-aided programming roles. This innovation also carries significant societal impacts, such as making AI systems more interpretable and therefore more trustworthy to the public. This interpretability could play a crucial role in fostering public confidence in AI technologies.
However, the journey toward AGI is fraught with challenges, both technological and ethical. The computational demands of program synthesis, coupled with the potential for negative impacts on creativity and digital content quality, are significant hurdles. Additionally, securing sustainable funding remains a concern as Ndea ramps up operations. Nevertheless, the initial public reception has been positive, particularly for the innovative synthesis of programmatic and deep learning methods, suggesting a strong foundation on which to build future success.
Unique AGI Approach of Ndea
Ndea is carving a niche in AGI research by fusing program synthesis with deep learning. This hybrid approach enables AI to learn and generalize from limited examples, a stark contrast to the methods employed by companies like OpenAI, which typically rely on vast datasets and compute resources. Program synthesis, akin to generating code from data instances, allows for greater adaptability and efficiency in AI, potentially overcoming the bottlenecks faced in current deep learning paradigms. François Chollet, co-founder of Ndea and creator of the Keras framework, recognizes program synthesis as a breakthrough area in AI, likening its current stage to the early days of deep learning. This conceptual fusion, still in its infancy, holds promise for unlocking unprecedented capabilities in AI systems.
The leadership behind Ndea brings rich expertise to the table. François Chollet, well-known for developing Keras, left his position at Google to fully immerse in this venture. His co-founder, Mike Knoop, formerly at the helm of Zapier's AI projects, complements Chollet's technical prowess with strategic oversight. Their partnership underscores a blend of innovative drive and seasoned leadership. While financial specifics about Ndea remain undisclosed, the ongoing recruitment efforts signal substantial backing, positioning them well for ambitious AGI development.
Ndea's initiative extends beyond mere commercial interests; they've also initiated a non-profit to establish benchmarks for AGI evaluation. These benchmarks aim to set the standard in assessing AGI technologies, promoting a fair and objective comparison across different approaches and platforms. The second-generation ARC-AGI benchmark is set for release, providing a framework for future AGI competitions and evaluations and ensuring the continuous integrity of AGI assessment.
The program synthesis aspect of Ndea's approach is drawing considerable attention and debate within the AI community. By allowing AI models to automatically generate functional code, it challenges the conventional reliance on extensive manual coding. This capability not only streamlines development but also enhances AI's ability to adapt to novel tasks, posing exciting opportunities for machine autonomy. However, the method demands a robust computational architecture to handle complexities inherent in synthesis tasks, a point of both technical intrigue and caution among experts.
Public reception of Ndea's strategy has been largely favorable, with many observers praising the innovative blend of program synthesis and deep learning. On platforms like X and LinkedIn, discussions highlight the potential for this approach to redefine AI's horizons. Enthusiasts on Reddit are exploring the technical nuances of program synthesis, forecasting potential breakthroughs in AI efficiency and capability. Despite the challenges, Ndea's unique pathway offers a refreshing departure from established methods, invoking curiosity and optimism throughout tech circles.
Current Developments and Future Plans
François Chollet, renowned for creating the popular AI framework Keras, has taken a significant leap in his career by departing from Google to found Ndea, a revolutionary AI startup. Alongside Mike Knoop, co-founder of Zapier, this ambitious new venture focuses on advancing the field of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). Utilizing a unique hybrid approach that marries program synthesis with deep learning techniques, Ndea aims to overcome the limitations of current deep learning systems by enabling AI to generalize from limited examples. This innovative approach sets Ndea apart from leading companies like OpenAI, promising a fresh direction in achieving continuous AI improvement.
The formation of Ndea has attracted significant attention in the AI community, particularly due to its focus on program synthesis. This technique allows AI systems to synthesize new programs from a few examples, potentially enhancing their ability to handle novel tasks efficiently, unlike traditional methods that require massive datasets. The company's commitment to creating AGI benchmarking standards through its related non-profit initiative points to their broader vision of shaping future AI industry norms. With recruitment for top-tier researchers in progress, Ndea is positioning itself as a frontier leader in the field of AGI innovation.
The excitement surrounding Ndea's launch extends beyond the company's innovative methods. François Chollet and Mike Knoop's leadership brings together a powerful blend of expertise in deep learning and entrepreneurial success. Chollet sees program synthesis as brimming with untapped potential, comparing its current stage to where deep learning was in 2012. This perspective aligns with independent expert analyses that endorse Ndea's hybrid approach of combining symbolic reasoning with neural networks, albeit recognizing that formidable technical challenges lie ahead.
Public reactions to Ndea's launch have been predominantly positive. On platforms like X and LinkedIn, there's been enthusiasm about the novel approach to AGI development through program synthesis. Reddit discussions are teeming with technical examinations of its potential to revolutionize AI. However, there are also voices of caution about the computational challenges intrinsic to program synthesis and Ndea's funding transparency, alongside broader concerns regarding AGI implications on human creativity and job displacement.
Looking forward, Ndea's innovative AGI approaches could have profound economic and social implications. The potential disruption of traditional software development looms as AI systems might automate coding tasks, which could create a fertile ground for new professions in AI-assisted programming. Furthermore, the enhanced interpretability of AI systems achieved by integrating program synthesis may bolster public trust in AI technologies, possibly mitigating concerns about technological inequality. These developments could redefine priorities in education, shifting towards a focus on creativity and reasoning, while establishing new benchmarks could streamline advancements across diverse scientific fields.
Funding and Recruitment Status
Ndea, co-founded by AI luminaries François Chollet and Mike Knoop, is actively addressing recruitment as they embark on their ambitious pursuit of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). Despite not having publicly disclosed funding details, the startup's extensive hiring efforts suggest they've secured substantial financial backing. This robust recruitment drive aligns with the company's broader strategy to establish a team capable of pushing the boundaries of program synthesis and deep learning, critical to their unique AGI approach. Current roles are likely focused on research and development, aimed at innovating beyond the existing paradigms set by AI giants like OpenAI.
In addition to active recruitment, Ndea has also initiated a non-profit to spearhead AGI benchmarking, ensuring a rigorous framework for measuring AGI capabilities. This initiative underscores the founders' commitment to transparency and collaboration within the AI community, possibly attracting top-tier talent interested in shaping not just technology, but the ethical and evaluative landscape of AGI. The broad industry interest in their non-profit endeavor further indicates potential strategic alliances that may bolster both funding and recruitment in the longer term.
Program Synthesis Explained
Program synthesis is an approach in artificial intelligence research that focuses on enabling machines to automatically generate programs that can solve specific problems based on a limited set of examples or specifications. François Chollet's new startup, Ndea, is at the forefront of using this technique to advance Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). Program synthesis helps bridge the gap between learning and reasoning by equipping AI systems with the ability to generalize from minimal data, thereby enhancing their problem-solving capabilities beyond what traditional machine learning systems can offer.
Ndea's unique approach combines program synthesis with deep learning methodologies. While deep learning has been widely successful in handling large datasets and enabling pattern recognition, it often struggles with generalizing to new, unseen tasks without extensive training. Program synthesis addresses this limitation by allowing the AI to construct solutions from scratch, effectively making it adaptable to a broader range of scenarios without requiring exhaustive re-training. This approach positions Ndea distinctively in the landscape of AI development, as it veers away from the conventional deep learning paths followed by industry giants like OpenAI.
The initiative by François Chollet and Mike Knoop is not just about technological advancement but also about setting new standards in AGI development. Their endeavor includes a non-profit aimed at creating benchmarks and standards for AGI, providing a unified framework to evaluate different AGI models' progress and performance. This aspect of Ndea's mission could play a pivotal role in shaping the future course of the AI industry by fostering more collaborative efforts and shared understanding among various stakeholders in the field.
Moreover, Ndea's focus on program synthesis is akin to finding a new frontier in AI research. By equipping AI with the ability to generate programs autonomously, this technique has the potential to revolutionize how we perceive and develop software and algorithms. This paradigm could lead to significant breakthroughs in various sectors, including software engineering, scientific research, and complex problem-solving industries, further pushing the boundaries of what AI can achieve.
Non-profit Initiative and AGI Benchmarking
In the realm of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), the establishment of Ndea, a non-profit initiative co-founded by François Chollet and Mike Knoop, marks a significant milestone. This venture focuses on AGI benchmarking, aiming to set industry standards. Chollet, known for creating Keras, has teamed up with Knoop from Zapier to innovate AGI through a combination of program synthesis and deep learning. This unique approach distinguishes Ndea from other AGI developers like OpenAI.
Ndea's creation is timely, considering the recent achievements and strategic moves within the AI sector. Notably, OpenAI's 'o3' model has achieved a significant AGI threshold, and the ARC Prize Foundation with Chollet and Knoop has been launched to develop new AGI benchmarks. These events underscore the vibrant and competitive landscape of AGI development that Ndea is stepping into. Additionally, heavy investments from industry leaders like Amazon and xAI indicate the growing interest and high stakes involved in AGI advancements.
The decision to launch a non-profit for AGI benchmarking is a strategic one. This initiative not only aims to create standardized benchmarks for assessing AGI progress but also seeks to foster a collaborative environment in the industry. By establishing these standards, the non-profit could greatly influence how progress in AGI is measured, potentially impacting future developments and guiding research efforts industry-wide.
Ndea’s approach to AGI focuses on leveraging program synthesis—a method that allows AI systems to create programs from given examples—alongside deep learning techniques. This is seen as a way to overcome the limitations of traditional deep learning systems, which rely heavily on large datasets. According to François Chollet, this innovative blend offers a "small but real chance" to achieve continuous AI improvement without the constraints that current systems face.
Experts in the field, like Dr. Gary Marcus, are aligning with Ndea’s strategy, highlighting its theoretical soundness despite the impending technical challenges. The fusion of symbolic reasoning and neural networks in Ndea's approach is appreciated for its potential to yield more adaptable and versatile AI systems. However, Chollet acknowledges that like deep learning in its early stages, program synthesis still holds undeveloped potential that needs exploration.
Public reactions to Ndea’s launch have been largely positive, with a keen interest in its innovative approach being expressed across social media. However, discussions on forums like Reddit point to complexities such as computational demands and long-term sustainability. Skeptics also voice concerns about potential impacts on human creativity and the future of job markets as AI continues to evolve.
The economic and social impacts of Ndea's venture are potentially far-reaching. By advancing AGI via program synthesis, traditional software development processes could be disrupted, paving the way for new job roles in AI-driven fields. Moreover, the balance of technological access could lead to disparities, reinforcing the importance of educational shifts towards creativity and reasoning skills rather than conventional programming.
Ndea's nonprofit venture could set the stage for scientific breakthroughs by establishing standardized AGI benchmarks. This could accelerate progress in drug discovery and other fields by enabling AI systems to tackle complex problems. Additionally, as AGI technologies evolve, they promise to reshape various industries, highlighting the necessity for robust oversight and ethical standards to guide this transformative journey.
Expert Opinions and Perspectives
François Chollet, a key figure in artificial intelligence due to his work on Keras, has embarked on a new venture with Mike Knoop from Zapier. Their startup, Ndea, focuses on advancing Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). What sets Ndea apart is its innovative application of program synthesis combined with deep learning techniques, positioning it distinctly from other AI giants like OpenAI.
Chollet recently left his position at Google to dedicate himself to Ndea, while Knoop balances his role by stepping back from his operational duties at Zapier to serve on its board. This initiative is not just about software development; it's a significant stride in the AI field which also includes a non-profit aimed at setting industry standards for AGI assessment.
Ndea's program synthesis approach allows for better AI generalization from minimal examples, which could potentially solve some fundamental limitations faced by current deep learning systems. The ambition of Ndea lies in its capacity to enable continuous AI improvement without bottlenecks, promising a paradigm shift similar to the early days of deep learning.
Chollet and Knoop’s non-profit endeavors to establish benchmarks that could standardize the industry’s approach to measuring AGI progress. Such measures are crucial for ensuring that AGI development is both progressive and safe, minimizing risks while maximizing the potential for groundbreaking advancements.
Experts in the field, such as Dr. Gary Marcus, have expressed support for the hybrid approach of combining symbolic reasoning with neural networks that Ndea is pursuing. This perspective suggests a sound theoretical foundation, although the venture must navigate the technical complexities to avoid potential pitfalls.
Public reception to Ndea's announcement has been largely positive, with social media conversations reflecting excitement and curiosity about this new direction in AI. Reddit users, in particular, have engaged in technical discussions about the potential impact of Ndea's methodology, indicating a robust interest in its application and success.
Public Reactions and Social Media Feedback
The unveiling of Ndea has ignited an extensive dialogue on social media, capturing the interest of a broad audience. Many tech enthusiasts and specialists are voicing their excitement on platforms like X and LinkedIn, particularly about the distinct path Ndea is taking. With its focus on program synthesis, Ndea diverges significantly from the deep learning methods traditionally used by companies such as OpenAI, sparking curiosity and optimism among followers. This innovative approach is seen as a bold move that could potentially redefine the capabilities of AI systems.
Discussion among tech communities on Reddit has been particularly vibrant, with users delving into the technicalities of program synthesis and debating its prospective influence on AI's future development. This discourse highlights a common sentiment of optimism, as enthusiasts speculate about the breakthrough possibilities this method could unlock in the AI research field. However, the method's complexity is not without its challenges, and users are mindful of the computational hurdles that lie ahead.
Despite the overall positive reception, some cautionary perspectives have emerged. Critics cite potential computational difficulties and the implications these might have on both the pace and quality of human creativity, stoking concerns about the broader impact on social media content. Questions around Ndea's financial stability and its ability to sustain such an ambitious project over the long term are also surfacing, adding a layer of skepticism amid the enthusiasm.
In addition to the technical debates, there's notable concern about the broader societal implications of AGI, as discussed on platforms like Medium. Users worry about the possible ramifications on human creativity and the quality of content, as AI-generated outputs become more prevalent. These discussions reflect a growing awareness of the potential for significant changes in content creation dynamics, driven by advancements in AGI.
As the conversation unfolds, it is becoming clear that Ndea's venture, with its innovative blend of program synthesis and deep learning, is set to influence public perception of AI. This endeavor not only underscores the potential for new technological horizons but also the need for careful consideration of the social and ethical dimensions associated with AI advancements.
Economic Implications of AGI
The emergence of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) promises to have profound economic implications, potentially reshaping industries and altering the workforce landscape. One pivotal area of impact is the software development sector. Program synthesis-based AGI, like the one pursued by Ndea, could revolutionize how software is created, significantly reducing the need for traditional coding roles while spawning new opportunities in AI-assisted programming. This shift may result in a fundamental transformation of employment dynamics within tech companies, as roles evolve to accommodate new technological paradigms.
Moreover, the competitive landscape among leading AI firms—such as Ndea, OpenAI, and Anthropic—could intensify, leading to accelerated innovation in the race towards more advanced AGI systems. This competitive drive might spur further investments into AI research and development, potentially creating market volatility, particularly within the AI-focused investment sector. As companies vie to unlock AGI's full potential, they may contribute to a continual surge in technological advancements, raising the importance of strategic financial planning and risk assessment in AI investments.
The advent of AGI also heralds the emergence of new job categories focused on program synthesis and AGI supervision. As traditional machine learning engineering roles undergo significant evolution, the demand for expertise in overseeing AGI operations and extracting actionable insights from AI-driven systems will likely increase. Consequently, educational institutions and training programs may need to adjust their curriculums to better prepare the workforce for these burgeoning roles, emphasizing skills aligned with AGI management and application.
Furthermore, AGI's role in driving economic transformation is not without its potential societal ramifications. The introduction of AGI systems that can interpret tasks and enhance decision-making processes might lead to increased public trust in AI technologies, as their applications become more transparent and understandable. However, there is a concomitant risk of exacerbating technological inequalities. Organizations with early access to AGI capabilities could gain substantial competitive advantages, potentially widening the gap between tech-savvy enterprises and those lagging in AI adoption.
Finally, AGI's potential to impact economic growth extends beyond corporate environments, influencing broader societal structures such as education and research. Standardized benchmarks for AGI performance—like those developed by Ndea's non-profit arm—may facilitate more targeted advancements in AI technologies, thereby accelerating scientific breakthroughs in diverse fields, including drug discovery and complex problem-solving across industries. As AGI capabilities continue to evolve, they are poised to play a crucial role in shaping the next wave of economic and technological progress.
Social Impact and Education Transformation
The landscape of education is bound for a monumental shift with the evolution of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), as pioneered by François Chollet and his co-founder Mike Knoop through the launch of Ndea. This transformational journey promises to redefine learning paradigms, focusing more on human creativity and reasoning as central tenets, rather than traditional programming methods. Chollet's emphasis on program synthesis, which champions AI's ability to generalize from minimal examples, speaks to a future where educational content is more integrated with AI capabilities, fostering environments that prioritize critical thinking and problem-solving skills for students.
The anticipated impact of AGI on social structures extends to educational transformations that could fundamentally alter how knowledge is imparted and assimilated. As AI becomes more interpretable—thanks to the innovative approaches like program synthesis by Ndea—public trust in AI technologies is expected to rise, creating educational systems that not only utilize AI as a tool for learning but also instill a sense of ethics and responsibility in its use. The AGI-driven change promises to cultivate a generation equipped with skills necessary for thriving in a technology-driven future, potentially bridging gaps between technology enthusiasts and skeptics.
In addition to enhancing educational quality, the integration of AGI approaches like those proposed by Ndea holds the potential to mitigate educational disparities. By providing more widely accessible AI tools, such technologies aim to democratize education, ensuring that advanced learning resources are not confined to a privileged few but are available to diverse populations globally. These AI systems could allow personalized learning paths that adapt to individual student needs, fostering inclusivity and catering to a variety of learning paces and styles.
The long-term implications of AGI's influence on education are profound. As these systems grow and evolve, they offer the potential to become co-educators alongside human teachers, providing supplemental education that is both data-driven and empathetically aligned with human values. Such a synergy could produce not only more knowledgeable individuals but well-rounded, ethically conscious global citizens prepared for the challenges of an AI-enhanced world. This echoes the envisioned transformation underscored by experts like Dr. Gary Marcus and aligns with Ndea’s mission to combine program synthesis and deep learning for unprecedented educational advancements.
Research & Development Opportunities
The continual evolution of technology promises a treasure trove of opportunities, particularly in the field of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). As we edge closer to realizing AGI, a crucial understanding of the landscape and potential opportunities for research and development is paramount. Companies like Ndea, founded by AI luminaries François Chollet and Mike Knoop, are paving the path forward by uniquely combining program synthesis with deep learning methodologies. This unconventional approach is poised to differentiate them from other industry frontrunners such as OpenAI.
Program synthesis, a methodology wherein AI generates computer programs from limited examples, introduces a novel way of achieving AGI. Ndea’s focus on this approach could potentially unlock superior AI systems capable of efficiently generalizing new tasks without relying on expansive datasets. The initiative not only holds promise for advancing AI technology but also for setting new standards in AI capability evaluation through their non-profit arm dedicated to AGI benchmarking.
Research and development in AGI are further buoyed by strategic partnerships and significant investments in the field. For instance, substantial financial commitments by companies like Amazon toward technology companies such as Anthropic signal strong industry confidence in the potential of AGI advancements to redefine technological and industrial landscapes. Moreover, other startups, such as Safe Superintelligence, are concurrently advancing research in safe AGI system development, ensuring the balance between technological innovation and ethical considerations.
The potential implications of AGI on society and the economy are profound. AGI might revolutionize traditional software development, potentially disrupting existing job markets and cultivating new roles centered around AI-assisted development and supervision. Such technological advancements could lead to increased public trust in AI systems due to their improved interpretability and reliability. However, this also brings forth challenges such as technological disparity among organizations and shifts in educational paradigms away from traditional programming toward fostering human creativity.
In conclusion, the future holds exciting possibilities as AGI research continues to evolve. Continued collaboration among scientists, researchers, and industry leaders is vital in overcoming the technical challenges that lie ahead. Establishing standardized benchmarks for AGI, as pursued by Ndea, is crucial in ensuring measurable and focused progress. As AGI systems grow more capable of addressing complex scientific and societal challenges, the quest for advanced AI technologies seems more promising than ever.